Bay Colony · Pelican Bay

Selling at Bay Colony

Discreet pricing, refined presentation, and disciplined negotiation for Bay Colony towers, villas, and beachfront estates.

Selling at Bay Colony

Selling at Bay Colony means pricing and presenting a beachfront or Gulf-view residence for a small, discerning buyer pool, with careful attention to view, floor level, building condition, and privacy throughout the process. Jeremy O’Guinn, Broker Associate and Certified Negotiation Expert with Downing-Frye Realty, guides Bay Colony owners from valuation through closing.

Bay Colony buyers are experienced, well informed, and often compare residences across several towers and estates. An effective strategy has to reflect the specific building, view, and floor, not just the Bay Colony name.

The approach is calm, strategic, and discreet. The goal is not just to list the residence. It is to position it for qualified buyers, protect your negotiating leverage, and present it at the standard Bay Colony demands.

18+Years in Naples
200+Homes Sold
CNECertified Negotiator
130+Five-Star Reviews
Bay Colony high-rise residences along the Gulf of Mexico beach in Pelican Bay, Naples, Florida
Pricing

How Your Bay Colony Residence Should Be Priced

What drives value in Bay Colony towers and estates

Pricing at Bay Colony depends on the specific features that drive demand for your kind of residence. Two units in the same tower can sit in very different price lanes, and an estate is compared against a different set of homes altogether.

  • High-rise residences: view orientation (Gulf, bay, or preserve), floor level, private elevator access, and renovation level
  • Estates: beachfront or lot position, privacy, and whether the home is new construction or original
  • Any residence: building condition, reserves and assessments, and current competition

For a quiet first step, request a confidential valuation and Jeremy will prepare a Bay Colony-specific valuation framework for your residence.

Preparation and Marketing

Preparing and Marketing Your Residence

Refinement, presentation, and targeted exposure

Preparing Before You List

Preparation at this level is about refinement, not renovation for its own sake. Buyers compare condition and presentation closely, so small, targeted improvements can have an outsized impact.

  • A pre-listing walkthrough focused on value, not busywork
  • Staging and styling guidance to elevate light, space, and views
  • Lanai and outdoor living areas polished and photo-ready
  • Association and club documents ready for buyer requests
  • Inspection-minded preparation to reduce friction during due diligence

How Your Residence Is Marketed

Marketing should reflect what buyers are really purchasing: the view, the privacy, the private clubs, and the Gulf. Every listing receives the same full plan, with no tiers or add-ons.

  • Professional photography and aerial imagery with a refined, editorial look
  • A property narrative that speaks to lifestyle, not just square footage
  • A dedicated property page and targeted online exposure
  • Agent-to-agent outreach to bring qualified buyers quietly
  • Private previews designed to protect your privacy
Discretion

Can You Sell Your Bay Colony Residence Quietly?

Private and off-market options for Bay Colony owners

For owners who value privacy, there are options between a full public launch and no marketing at all. Depending on your goals and timeline, private or off-market approaches can include previews for qualified buyers and agents before any public listing.

  • Private showings by appointment with screened buyers
  • Limited-exposure or off-market options where appropriate
  • Careful handling of owner information throughout the process

Limited exposure can narrow the buyer pool, so you will see the trade-offs before deciding.

The Transaction

Clubs, Associations, and Negotiation

Preparing answers early and protecting your position

Clubs, Associations, and Building Condition

Bay Colony buyers often ask about beach club and tennis club membership, association dues, reserves, special assessments, and the building’s inspection status. Addressing these early prevents surprises later.

  • Confirm current club membership terms and costs for your residence
  • Gather association documents, dues, and reserve information in advance
  • Understand any recent or planned building work and assessments
  • Prepare a clear, buyer-friendly summary before the first showing

Showings, Offers, and Negotiation

The best negotiation happens before the offer arrives: presentation, clarity, disclosure strategy, and a showing plan that builds demand.

  • A showing plan built around qualified, pre-screened buyers
  • Offer evaluation beyond price, including terms, proof of funds, and timeline
  • An inspection strategy that keeps the deal moving while protecting your position
  • Association approval steps managed where applicable
  • A clean contract path with clear dates and responsibilities
Jeremy O'Guinn, Bay Colony listing agent and Certified Negotiation Expert at Downing-Frye Realty
Your Bay Colony Advisor

What Is Your Bay Colony Residence Worth?

Broker Associate · Certified Negotiation Expert · Downing-Frye Realty

“The most reliable way to estimate value is to compare your residence to the right subset of Bay Colony sales, whether that is the same tower, a comparable view and floor, or a similar estate. Share the address, and I’ll prepare a confidential valuation range and a recommended strategy.”
 
“Selling from out of state could have been difficult, but Jeremy handled the details beautifully and kept everything moving.”
Out-of-State Seller · Naples condo sale
Questions

Selling at Bay Colony: FAQ

Pricing, timing, privacy, and preparation

What makes Bay Colony different from other Naples luxury communities?

Bay Colony is a gated beachfront enclave within Pelican Bay with its own private beach and tennis clubs, Gulf-view high-rise residences, and beachfront estates, a combination that draws a small and discerning pool of buyers.

How do you determine the right listing price for a Bay Colony residence?

Pricing is based on closed sales and active competition within the same building or estate category, then adjusted for view, floor level or lot position, renovation quality, and building condition.

When is the best time to sell at Bay Colony?

The best time depends on inventory levels, your residence’s condition, and your timeline. Seasonality matters in Southwest Florida, so launches are aligned with the strongest buyer demand window while the residence presents at its best.

Can I sell my Bay Colony residence privately or off-market?

In many cases, yes. Owners who prefer limited exposure can choose private or off-market options, including previews for qualified buyers and agents before any public launch, after weighing the trade-offs together.

Do club memberships and association rules affect my sale?

Yes. Buyers will ask about beach club and tennis club membership, association dues, reserves, and any assessments, so clear documentation assembled upfront helps avoid surprises during due diligence.

Do I need to renovate before selling?

Not always. The highest return usually comes from presentation-focused improvements, such as fresh paint, lighting, and minor repairs, guided by a prioritized plan so you only do what meaningfully improves market response.

What does it cost to list a Bay Colony residence with Jeremy?

Commission is agreed on for each listing based on the property, the market, and the marketing plan. Jeremy walks through the numbers for your specific residence before any commitment, with no pressure to list.

What is the first step to selling my Bay Colony residence?

Request a confidential valuation. Jeremy reviews recent sales in your building or estate category and follows up with a private conversation about pricing, timing, and strategy.

Seller Resources

More for Bay Colony Owners

Market data and guides to help you plan your next move.

The 239 Weekly

Naples Market Insight, Every Friday

Market updates, neighborhood insight, and Southwest Florida lifestyle, delivered weekly.

Ready When You Are

Request a Confidential Bay Colony Valuation

Get a clear, data-driven understanding of what your Bay Colony residence is worth in today’s market, shared privately.

Recently Sold in Bay Colony

8473 Bay Colony DR Unit 1401, Naples
$4,900,000
3 Beds ⋅ 3.5 Baths ⋅ 226009456 MLS ⋅ Biltmore At Bay Colony BLDG.
Look at these views—an extraordinary opportunity to own one of the most compelling residences in the Biltmore at Bay Colony. Perfectly positioned as a coveted end unit on the southernmost side of the building. This southwest-facing residence captures sweeping, unobstructed panoramas of the Gulf, delivering endless sunsets and sun-drenched living from every angle. From the moment you enter, you are greeted by a breathtaking visual connection to the shoreline, where natural light pours through expansive glass and elevates the home’s refined, minimalist aesthetic—creating a seamless flow between indoor elegance and outdoor beauty. The interior is thoughtfully designed with light French Oak hardwood flooring that mirrors the soft tones of the sandy beaches below, reinforcing a warm, coastal sophistication throughout. The flexible, open-concept floor plan presents a rare opportunity to tailor the living spaces to your lifestyle, whether envisioning a formal dining room, media lounge, or private den. The beachfront owner’s suite is a true retreat—generously scaled with a dedicated sitting or workspace niche, direct access to the covered lanai and a spa-inspired bath designed for relaxation. A private guest wing with 2 guest suites with en-suite baths ensures comfort and privacy, with both suites with eastern screened lanai access enjoy remarkable views stretching across Bay Colony and Pelican Bay. The kitchen is a chef’s showpiece featuring a premium Gaggenau appliance package, center island, breakfast bar and a sunlit breakfast nook. Entertaining is effortless, with a built-in bar anchoring the main living space and dual screened lanais offering both eastern and western exposures—perfect for morning coffee or evening cocktails with the Gulf as your backdrop. This residence is further distinguished by two deeded parking spaces and the unmatched lifestyle of the newly transformed Biltmore. Electric roll-down shutters provide peace of mind and protection, enhancing the lock-and-leave convenience that defines effortless seasonal living in Naples. Residents enjoy a completely reimagined arrival experience, elegant lobby, sophisticated social spaces, fitness center and an exceptional outdoor oasis featuring a resort-style pool, spa, fire pit & grilling areas—all supported by superior on-site management and a 24-hour staffed front desk ensures impeccable service. Just steps away, Bay Colony Beach Club offers a 5 star experience, fine dining, and full-service beachside amenities. The Bay Colony Tennis Club and private restaurant are moments away, while the world-class offerings of Pelican Bay—including additional beach clubs, tennis, pickleball, wellness centers, and tram service—expand your lifestyle even further. Ideally located just minutes from Mercato, Waterside Shops, Artis cultural and 5th Ave this is a rare opportunity to secure a premier coastal residence that delivers on every level—view, location, lifestyle, and long-term value.

8473 Bay Colony DR Unit 1401, Naples

9758 Niblick LN, Naples
$5,800,000
4 Beds ⋅ 4.5 Baths ⋅ 226024716 MLS
An elegantly updated private oasis in the heart of Naples’ most prestigious golf community, this custom home has benefitted from extensive high-quality improvements over the last 5 years, and the light pastel palette throughout adds desirable ‘coastal’ flair and a tranquil ambiance. Offered ‘turnkey’, with recent, stylish furnishings and accessories from Bay Designs and Robb & Stucky. The generously proportioned home features a 2-story living room with coffered ceiling, gas fireplace and newly designed wet-bar area with quartzite countertop, wine refrigerator and ice-maker. The bright family room has walls of glass sliders, a breakfast niche, and flows to the reconfigured kitchen with a large island and quartz countertops. The primary suite is a sanctuary, complete with sitting and exercise rooms, and there are 3 spacious guest suites, 2 with newly installed wide-plank wood flooring and completely new bathrooms. Lighting has been updated to dimmable LED 'Lutron' throughout, and there are remote-controlled shades to the rear windows and sliders. The outdoor areas are perfect for entertaining, with the oversized, totally renovated lanai featuring a gas fireplace and motorized screens, leading to the newly paved pool deck, outdoor built-in grill, resurfaced pool and spa, and extensive landscape lighting illuminates the lush tropical landscaping and preserve beyond. The list of upgrades is extensive, and owners in The Estates at Bay Colony Golf Club also enjoy membership of the exclusive Bay Colony Beach Club with elegant beachfront dining privileges, an active tennis program, and the many amenities and activities offered by the Pelican Marsh Community, including a full-service gym. Membership at Bay Colony Golf Club is immediately available if desired (and subject to approval), and an E-Z-Go 2022 golf cart is included!

9758 Niblick LN, Naples

8171 Bay Colony DR Unit 202, Naples
$3,500,000
3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 226027546 MLS ⋅ Carlysle At Bay Colony BLDG.
Enjoy the rare luxury of owning what feels like a Secret Villa tucked inside Carlysle, a stately and impressive Ritz Carlton caliber, direct Beachfront Bay Colony High-Rise Tower. This gem’s tasteful interior appointments are further enhanced by its rare, private stairway leading directly down to Carlyle’s just Re-Mastered, fabulous 5-Star luxurious resort style pool/spa and Naples’ renowned sugar white sandy beach just a few boardwalk steps beyond. Perched above Carlyle’s first level garage, second level Lobby and third level Amenity floor, this gem offers 180-degree unobstructed, private Gulf views from North to South, comparable in height to other 4th floor properties. Carefree 18” x 18” chiseled-edge stone flooring, fresh white custom kitchen and bath cabinetry, serving bar, hard surface counters, stainless built-in appliances and custom lighting are all designed for easy-breezy living. The generous Gulf-side Owner’s Suite offers a stunning Gulf-Front picture window, sumptuous bath with separate his and her private areas, along with two spacious walk-in closets. Both en-suite guest bedrooms plus the family room/den access a second, Easterly sunny morning screened lanai. Gracefully located just 4 towers south of the famed Naples Beachfront Ritz Carlton, Carlysle is a full-service concierge Tower offering 24/7 front desk personnel, professional full-time management, luxury spa-like resort pool/spa, grand social salon, library/board room, fitness, and two guest suites. Owners are privileged to enjoy both Bay Colony and Pelican Bay Private Membership, including: 3 private Beachfront Dining Clubs to call your own, 2½ miles of pristine sugar white sandy beach, attended Beachfront services, active Tennis Clubs, state-of-the-art Fitness, miles of biking and walking paths and much more! Artis Center for the Arts and Mercato both just steps away!

8171 Bay Colony DR Unit 202, Naples

8171 Bay Colony DR Unit 403, Naples
$3,350,000
3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 226003489 MLS ⋅ Carlysle At Bay Colony BLDG.
Direct beachfront luxury condo. Fully renovated with wood floors throughout, new kitchen with white quartz countertops and renovated baths. Impact windows and automated shutters on the lanai. Family room has beautiful new wood beams on the ceiling. Offering over 2,600 square feet of living space, this stunning condo feels like a single-family home, with panoramic Gulf views and refreshing trade winds from nearly every room. Enjoy the sugar sand beach right at your doorstep and experience front-row views of majestic sunrises and sunsets from the comfort of your two screened lanais. The Carlysle is among the most desirable buildings in Bay Colony, having just completed a fully remodel of the gorgeous lobby, new saltwater pool and spa, exercise room, manned front desk, two guest suites, bike storage, social rooms. From the grand lobby and front entrance to the refined elevator lobbies, meticulously designed driveway, and lush landscaping, every detail is truly remarkable. Residents of the Carlysle enjoy direct beach access, a beachfront pool, a well-appointed fitness center, and exclusive membership privileges at the Bay Colony Beach Club and Bay Colony Tennis. They also benefit from the full suite of lifestyle amenities within Pelican Bay, including miles of private beach, two additional beachfront restaurants, pickleball, a state-of-the-art fitness center, sailing, canoeing, miles of walking trails, and an active cultural and community scene. Parking space numbers are 90 & 116.

8171 Bay Colony DR Unit 403, Naples

8930 Bay Colony DR Unit 703, Naples
$3,107,000
3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 226009048 MLS ⋅ Salerno At Bay Colony BLDG.
Seamless, Sophisticated and Sunset-driven. Welcome to Salerno 703, a designer remodeled three-bedroom, three-bath residence in the prestigious gated enclave of Bay Colony. Western exposure bathes this home in golden afternoon light and captures breathtaking sunsets over the Gulf, a dynamic backdrop that transforms from day to night. Thoughtfully reimagined for today’s modern coastal lifestyle, the Wall between the kitchen and living room has been removed to create a Grand open-concept Great room where architecture disappears and the views take center stage. At its center, an exquisite marble peninsula anchors the space creating a stunning focal point and natural gathering place. Generous in scale, it offers ample seating for casual dining or elegant entertaining and provides additional storage and convenient Sub-Zero refrigerator drawers. Best-in-class Kitchen Appliances, Wolf, Sub-Zero and Miele offer culinary performance while showcasing sleek contemporary design and are highlighted by beautiful custom crafted cabinetry by Downsview. The spacious primary suite is a private retreat, while two additional guest bedrooms and full baths provide comfort and privacy for family and friends. The Salerno boasts a fully updated lobby level—an elegant transformation that sets a new standard for refined living. A professionally staffed concierge greets you upon arrival, while the beautifully designed social lounge invites connection and relaxation. You will enjoy a state-of-the-art fitness center, a resort style outdoor pool and dining area and the added benefit of well-appointed guest suites. Beyond the residence, Bay Colony offers a lifestyle reserved for the fortunate few with private beach access and attended service, a tennis center, an exclusive beach club and restaurant and beautifully maintained grounds. As a homeowner, you will further enjoy all the amenities of Pelican Bay, Southwest Florida’s most desired beachfront community.

8930 Bay Colony DR Unit 703, Naples

8473 Bay Colony DR Unit 304, Naples
$4,350,000
3 Beds ⋅ 4.5 Baths ⋅ 224080015 MLS ⋅ Biltmore At Bay Colony BLDG.
Step into move-in-ready, TURNKEY luxury—just in time for season. This exquisite corner end unit in the coveted ’04 stack, known as the most desirable floor plan in the building, offers panoramic perfection and a lifestyle defined by sophistication and ease. From the moment you enter, you’re greeted with breathtaking views in every direction. The scene is pure magic, capturing the essence of coastal living at its finest. Upgraded and thoughtfully curated with designer finishes and furniture, this residence exudes timeless elegance. The soft glow of Jerusalem Limestone flooring sets the tone for refined living, while Final Touch custom maple woodwork elevates each space with bespoke craftsmanship and attention to every detail. Every bedroom offers its own ensuite, providing comfort, privacy, and a true retreat for you and your guests. Enjoy your morning coffee as the first light dances across the horizon, then unwind at day’s end with a glass of wine as the sun sinks into the Gulf. Every moment here feels effortless and inspiring. Located just steps from the exclusive Bay Colony Beach Club, you’ll have access to beachfront chair and umbrella service, fine dining, and all the amenities that make this community so exceptional. Fully furnished, impeccably appointed, and ready for immediate enjoyment—this residence invites you to embrace the season ahead in pure Naples luxury!

8473 Bay Colony DR Unit 304, Naples

9655 Mashie CT, Naples
$8,450,000
5 Beds ⋅ 5.5 Baths ⋅ 226001752 MLS
Behind the gates of The Estates at Bay Colony Golf Club, this custom residence by Kraft Construction is a one-of-one offering, designed for buyers who want privacy, presence and a home that lives beautifully in every season. In a lush garden setting with a prized golf-course view, the home pairs soaring ceilings with warm wood floors and bespoke millwork, tile and finishes. At the heart of the home, an expansive renovated kitchen anchors daily life and effortless entertaining with generous prep space, abundant cabinetry and a layout made for family breakfasts, catered evenings and everything in between. The adjacent family room is elevated by a dedicated bar, creating a natural gathering space that transitions seamlessly from casual afternoons to cocktail hour. Throughout, the scale is impressive yet comfortable, with thoughtful sight lines, volume, and architectural detail that signal custom quality. Featuring four full bedroom suites, including a standout cabana guest suite that offers a rare sense of separation and independence. Connected by a covered and screened outdoor living area, the cabana creates the feel of a private guest wing, ideal for long-stay visitors, multi-generational living, or anyone who values their retreat. A home office supports a work-from-home lifestyle. For evenings in the club room (optional fifth bedroom), it is a destination of its own, complete with an additional full bath, making it ideal for game-day hosting, movie nights, or a relaxed lounge that keeps entertaining contained and comfortable. Outdoor living is equally compelling, including a covered and screened sitting area with fireplace and a summer kitchen with built-in grill that sets the stage for alfresco dining, while the large pool and spa invite quiet mornings, sunlit afternoons and lingering evenings under the palms. The overall effect is a private, resort-style backdrop with calm beauty of the golf course beyond. Life here includes membership to the Bay Colony Beach Club, offering beachfront dining, a beachside pool and chair service for effortless days on the Gulf. Residents also enjoy access to the Pelican Marsh fitness and tennis and pickleball center, adding a second layer of lifestyle value beyond the gates. Bay Colony Golf Club membership is optional, giving owners the freedom to enjoy the setting and amenities now, and decide on golf later. Extraordinary in finish, rare in layout and unmatched in lifestyle access, this is one of Naples distinctive golf course offerings, created for those who want a refined home that entertains flawlessly, lives privately and delivers the Bay Colony standard of elegance.

9655 Mashie CT, Naples

8111 Bay Colony DR Unit 1102, Naples
$2,875,000
2 Beds ⋅ 2.5 Baths ⋅ 225080707 MLS ⋅ Contessa At Bay Colony BLDG.
Experience luxury beachfront living at its finest in this beautifully maintained residence located within the prestigious guard gated community of Bay Colony. Perched on the eleventh floor, this elegant sky home offers sweeping unobstructed views of the Gulf from nearly every room along with a coastal contemporary design that feels both refined and inviting. Step off the elevator into the freshly updated lobby level and enter your residence where floor to ceiling glass, abundant natural light, and an open spacious layout create an effortless flow ideal for both everyday living and entertaining. The great room opens to an oversized beachfront terrace that is perfect for morning coffee, evening cocktails, and enjoying nightly sunsets over the Gulf of Mexico. The kitchen features custom Poggenpohl cabinetry, high end appliances, quartz counters, and a large island with seating. The primary suite is a serene retreat with breathtaking water views, a spa inspired bath, and generous custom closets. Two beautifully appointed guest suites offer comfort and privacy for visiting family and friends. Located in one of Bay Colony’s premier luxury towers, residents enjoy world class amenities including a beachfront pool and spa, fitness center, newly renovated lobby and social spaces, guest suites, a staffed front desk around the clock, and secure under building parking. Ownership in Bay Colony also provides access to the Bay Colony Beach Club with private dining, the Bay Colony Tennis Club, and miles of pristine patrolled white sand beaches. All of this is just minutes to the Ritz Carlton, Waterside Shops, Artis Naples, and the fine dining and conveniences that make Pelican Bay and Bay Colony two of the most sought after beachfront communities in Naples. This is a rare opportunity to own an exceptional Gulf front residence in one of Naples most exclusive enclaves.

8111 Bay Colony DR Unit 1102, Naples

Start Your Search

The data relating to real estate for sale on this web site comes in part from the Broker Reciprocity Program (BR Program) of M.L.S. of Naples, Inc. Properties listed with brokerage firms other than this company are marked with the BR Program Icon or the BR House Icon and detailed information about them includes the name of the listing brokers. The properties displayed may not be all the properties available through the BR Program. The information provided is for consumers’ personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any other purpose.

How much is your home worth?

Get instant property value now!