Market report, updated

Bay Colony Real Estate Market Insider

Search in the neighborhoods of Bay Colony, Pelican Bay, and Pelican Marsh, in the subdivisions of Bay Colony Shores, Biltmore At Bay Colony, Brighton At Bay Colony, and other subdivisions, in the city of Naples

Create your own market report
Naplesnest.com logo
Report prepared by Naplesnest.com
Market Report • Bay Colony • Pelican Bay, Naples, Florida

About This Bay Colony Market Report

This report tracks active Bay Colony listings and properties sold within the past six months in Pelican Bay, Naples, Florida. Bay Colony is the most exclusive private enclave within Pelican Bay, gated separately with its own beach club, tennis facilities, and dedicated concierge services. The community spans Gulf-front and Gulf-view high-rise condominiums along the beachfront and single-family estate homes on the interior. Each segment attracts a different buyer profile and operates at a different absorption rate, and market data is most reliably interpreted within those segments rather than as a community-wide average. The report includes the Bay Colony towers and villas, the estates of Bay Colony Shores and The Strand, and the nearby Estates at Bay Colony Golf Club in Pelican Marsh.

Reading the Report

How to Interpret Bay Colony Market Data

Active Listings

Properties currently offered for sale. In Bay Colony, note whether the listing is a Gulf-front high-rise condominium or an interior estate home, as these represent separate markets competing for different buyer profiles.

Days on Market (DOM)

Days in the current listing period. DOM resets on relisting and may significantly understate total market exposure. Extended DOM within Bay Colony typically reflects overpricing relative to competing inventory in the same building and floor range rather than a broadly weak market for the enclave overall.

Sold Price

Final closed price after negotiation. The most reliable evidence of current market value. Within Bay Colony condominiums, comparables should be filtered by building, floor tier, and direct-versus-angled Gulf view before drawing price conclusions.

Price Per Square Foot

Variable across Bay Colony. A Gulf-front unit on a high floor and an interior estate home can show dramatically different per-square-foot figures for reasons unrelated to relative market strength. Always interpret within segment.

Bay Colony Premium

Bay Colony commands a premium within Pelican Bay reflecting its separate gate, private beach club, dedicated tennis facilities, and concierge services. This premium must be explicitly factored into comparisons against non-Bay-Colony Pelican Bay sales, which otherwise appear to be the closest comps on paper.

For a property-specific valuation accounting for floor, view, building, and current competition within Bay Colony, a targeted comparable analysis is available upon request.

Bay Colony Market Context

What Makes Bay Colony a Distinct Market Within Pelican Bay

Bay Colony is gated separately within Pelican Bay and operates as its own real estate submarket with its own supply constraints, buyer pool, and pricing dynamics. Buyers specifically targeting Bay Colony are evaluating the private beach club, dedicated tennis, and separate gate as non-negotiable amenities that justify a material premium over the balance of Pelican Bay. The reliable comparison set for any Bay Colony property is other Bay Colony listings and recent Bay Colony sales, not Pelican Bay broadly.

Gulf-Front CondominiumsHigh-rise buildings directly on the Gulf with views and beach access. Floor level and view angle are the primary pricing differentiators within any given building. HOA financial health and milestone inspection status are critical due diligence items.
Interior Estate HomesSingle-family residences within the Bay Colony gate. Lot size, renovation quality, and outdoor living condition are the primary value drivers. Bay Colony estate buyers also compare against similarly-priced homes in Park Shore, Moorings, and Old Naples.
The Bay Colony PremiumThe private gate, beach club, and dedicated services are consistently cited by buyers as the reason they pay a premium over Pelican Bay. Marketing that fails to communicate this premium clearly leaves value on the table for sellers.
Need a Sharper Read?

Request a Bay Colony Property-Specific Analysis

Community-level data provides context. A targeted comparable review for your specific building, floor, view, or estate home delivers considerably more actionable guidance for any Bay Colony buying or selling decision.

Bay Colony Market Insider: Frequently Asked Questions
How often is the Bay Colony market report updated?
Updated regularly with current listing inventory and the most recent six months of closed sales activity within Bay Colony in Pelican Bay.
Should I compare Bay Colony condos against all Pelican Bay condos?
No. Bay Colony commands a documented premium over the balance of Pelican Bay due to its separate gate, private beach club, and dedicated services. Using non-Bay-Colony Pelican Bay sales as direct comparables will undervalue Bay Colony properties. The reliable comparison set is other Bay Colony buildings, filtered by floor tier and view orientation.
What drives pricing differences between Bay Colony buildings?
Building location, direct versus angled Gulf exposure, floor level, renovation quality, HOA financial health, and milestone inspection status are all meaningful pricing factors. Two units of similar square footage in different Bay Colony buildings can trade at materially different prices based on these variables.
What does extended days on market mean for a Bay Colony listing?
In a market with limited inventory, extended DOM almost always signals overpricing for the specific floor, view, and condition rather than a broad softening of demand. Confirm whether the DOM figure has reset from a prior listing period, which would understate total market exposure time.
How do I get an accurate Bay Colony property valuation?
A reliable valuation requires comparable sales filtered by building, floor tier, view orientation, and renovation level. A confidential property-specific analysis is available upon request and accounts for all these variables rather than relying on community or zip-code level averages.

Market at a glance

Over the last 6 months, homes sold for 93.1% of list price in 152 days on average.

Average price, last 12 months

What sellers asked vs. what homes actually sold for, by closing month.

List · $4.5M Sold · $4.42M
$7.1M$5.6M$4.1M$2.6M
NovDecJanFebMarAprMayJunJulAugSepOct

Homes sold per month

Closed sales, last 12 months.

Sold tab (last 6 months) Earlier

Peak: 6 sales in Jan. Last month: 2.

Where the market stands

All homes in this report, by status.

47homes
Active28 · 60%
Under contract5 · 11%
Sold (6 mo)14 · 30%

Buyer's or seller's market?

Months it would take to sell every active home at the pace of the last 6 months.

10.5months of inventory
Seller's, under 4BalancedBuyer's, over 6

Buyers have room to negotiate in this market.

Average price by status

Active$8.23M
Under contract$7.79M
Sold$4.52M

Average days on market

Active82 days
Under contract263 days
Sold152 days

Browse homes by status

Choose a status to see its numbers, charts and listings.

Active homes

Currently for sale
Homes for sale 28
Average list price $8,225,321
Avg. days on market 82 days
Avg. price per ft² $1,790
Avg. living area 4,411 ft²
Avg. beds / baths 3.6 / 4.3

Price vs. living area

Each dot is a home. Hover a dot for its address, click it to see the home.

$60M$40M$20M$0

Price vs. living area: 28 homes plotted, up to $60M and 9,000 ft².

0 ft²3,0006,0009,000 ft²

How long homes have been listed

Number of homes by days on market.

Bedroom mix

Number of homes by bedroom count.

Highest price per ft²

Top 7 homes in this status.

7409 Bay Colony DR$4,299
8665 BAY COLONY DR Unit 1202$3,432
8665 Bay Colony DR Unit 1403$3,430
8473 Bay Colony DR Unit PH2202$2,891
8231 Bay Colony DR Unit 704$2,179
8477 Bay Colony DR Unit PH17$1,929
8473 Bay Colony DR Unit 1602$1,922

All active listings

Click a column to sort
AddressBedsBathsLiving ft²List price$ / ft²Days on market
8665 Bay Colony DR Unit 1403Naples, FL 34108 33.53,390$11,630,000$3,4301 day
333 Sedgwick CTNaples, FL 34108 67.56,622$11,395,000$1,72014 days
8473 Bay Colony DR Unit PH2202Naples, FL 34108 56.57,262$20,995,000$2,89116 days
7913 Via VecchiaNaples, FL 34108 33.52,671$4,995,000$1,87021 days
8960 Bay Colony DR Unit 602Naples, FL 34108 332,520$2,950,000$1,17023 days
8787 Bay Colony DR Unit 2005Naples, FL 34108 33.53,415$4,995,000$1,46225 days
8665 BAY COLONY DR Unit 1202Naples, FL 34108 332,870$9,850,000$3,43228 days
8473 Bay Colony DR Unit 1602Naples, FL 34108 332,860$5,499,000$1,92232 days
8231 Bay Colony DR Unit 704Naples, FL 34108 22.52,980$6,495,000$2,17937 days
9880 Brassie BENDNaples, FL 34108 56.58,355$10,750,000$1,28657 days
Naplesnest.com logo

Questions about this market?

These numbers move every month. For what they mean for your home, or for a home you have your eye on, get in touch.

Naplesnest.com

Next steps

Get a Confidential Home Value 

Every valuation begins with current local market data and is handled discreetly.  Automated estimates provide a helpful starting point and are personally reviewed to account for important details that automated tools may miss.

Free and instant. We can follow up with a detailed valuation.

The data relating to real estate for sale on this web site comes in part from the Broker Reciprocity Program (BR Program) of M.L.S. of Naples, Inc. Properties listed with brokerage firms other than this company are marked with the BR Program Icon or the BR House Icon and detailed information about them includes the name of the listing brokers. The properties displayed may not be all the properties available through the BR Program. The information provided is for consumers’ personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any other purpose.